Context 170 - December 2021
C O N T E X T 1 7 0 : D E C E M B E R 2 0 2 1 45 an enforcement notice, ordering the owner to ‘recreate in facsimile the building as it stood immediately prior to its demolition’. They were also prevented from selling the site until the pub had been rebuilt ‘brick by brick’ and were given two years to do so. The owner’s appeal against this decision was rejected at public inquiry. The planning inspector took the pub’s special interest into account, agreeing that it was ‘highly likely that it would have been listed had it not been demolished’. The enforcement order required the pub to be rebuilt before July 2018 and, although delayed, it finally reopened in April 2021. Comparisons England and Australia have similarly sophisti- cated enforcement frameworks for the protec- tion of heritage assets but both countries also have difficulties in enacting these powers. In England, this is down to resources, but when prosecution is clearly in the public interest, powers are shown to be effective. In Australia, hurdles can often be unsurmountable, with exorbitant land prices and the lobbying power of private developers undermining the effec- tiveness of heritage enforcement, particularly when fines for demolition can be many times lower than the profit from new development. In England, active participation of local com- munities is encouraged (if sometimes begrudg- ingly) at all levels, including the identification of heritage assets for designation, input into local plan policies and comments on specific devel- opments.The discretionary system ensures that community voices are a material consideration for decision makers. The tradition of heritage protection in England ensures that it continues to hold significant sway over the land-use planning system, with policies often working in the public interest. While this system is not perfect, it appears to offer greater participatory power than the public is afforded in Australia. Due to the economic pressures on land use, the regulatory system offers little flexibility for engagement. But grass- roots activity is starting to shift the balance of power, illustrating local communities’ interest in their historic past. The cases of the Carlton Tavern and the Corkman Pub allow us to reflect on the effec- tiveness of heritage protection frameworks in each country.This is arguably strong in England, thanks to its early adoption, robust integration into the planning system and its ongoing adapta- tion to shifting heritage philosophies. It can withstand the economic market pressures that more immature frameworks struggle to cope with, through lack of integrated or enforceable measures. Australian conservation philosophy holds international significance for its contribution to the global heritage management discourse, but the regional regulatory planning systems that control change do not place the same level of value on heritage, reducing planners ability to guard against the economic pressures of inap- propriate development. However, we can end on a note of hopefulness for Australian heritage. In a direct response to the Corkman Pub case, the Victorian parliament passed legislation in March 2021 to prevent a similar situation from arising again. The new law will allow exist- ing permits to be revoked from sites that are illegally demolished, provide powers to stop development on sites for 10 years and increase indictable offences. Melburnians may yet find themselves drinking in the Corkman Pub again. Rebecca Burrows is head of heritage with the planning consultancy Lanpro. The Carlton Tavern, Kilburn, following its demolition in 2015 (Photo: Purcell)
Made with FlippingBook
RkJQdWJsaXNoZXIy MjgyMjA=