Context 168 - June 2021

38 C O N T E X T 1 6 8 : J U N E 2 0 2 1 brought into question. After the first world war a cenotaph was proposed to replace the Albert Memorial. This did not happen but it represented a shift in appreciation of the monu- ment and a disdain for Victorian architecture in the early 20th century. The memorial suffered several decades of neglect until a number of its pinnacles and sculptures were taken down on health and safety grounds in 1950. Although listed Grade II in 1963, opinion was still polar- ised, with one councillor describing it as ‘a very expensive pigeon loft which ought to be demolished forthwith’. When urgent repairs were undertaken another councillor suggested ‘a stick of dynamite as more appropriate’. By 1971 the council voted 71–31 in favour of demolition. However, largely through the efforts of theVictorian Society and its Save Albert cam- paign, the building was upgraded from Grade II to Grade I, and ultimately restored in 1978. Although much of the 1978 conservation work is questionable by modern standards, the actions of the conservation lobby saved the memorial. When constructed, the memorial had decora- tive metalwork railings, designed by Thomas Worthington and produced by Skidmore’s Art Manufacturers Company of Coventry. During both world wars the railings remained and were not removed as was common as part of the war effort. Documentary evidence shows that the railings remained until at least 1946. They have since been removed, although when and why is not known. The original drawings have been found in the Manchester Metropolitan University archive, illustrating the openwork quatrefoils within vertical panels, a decorative frieze, and top rail with cresting and finials. The documentary evidence provided a sound basis for restoration: the railings will be reinstated as part of the repair and conservation package to conserve the monument, along with improve- ments to lighting and repairs to masonry. In 1986 a major scheme for Albert Square pushed vehicular routes to the extremities of the square and replaced the paving, creating the arrangement seen today. The removal of traffic from the front of the town hall meant that the square ceased to be a traffic island and a large area was opened for pedestrian use.This scheme represented a positive step in enhancing the historic characteristics of the space associated with free movement and visual openness. While the 1980s scheme represented a considerable improvement, it did not entirely address the issue of intrusive traffic, which continues to create uncharacteristic barriers in this civic space. Piecemeal changes, including areas of tarmacadam patching and other clutter, also detract from the square’s heritage. The design approach to Albert Square has been defined by thorough investigation of the space and through numerous stakeholder engagements, consultation events and work- shops.This collaborative approach has identified a series of challenges and assessed how they might inform positive design concepts that define the character of the space. These are pri- marily security and counter terrorism; highways and road geometry; the events strategy; heritage and the setting of the town hall and surrounding buildings; the approach to historic monuments; and the approach to existing mature trees. As these issues are so interdependent, a holis- tic approach has been taken to ensure there is coherence between the different strategies. The approach to managing traffic has been somewhat dovetailed with the need to provide adequate hostile vehicle mitigation measures to make the space safe. This is underpinned by an ambition to create an inspiring space that is defined by its building edges and not by the highway that currently dominates it. This led to the decision to close several of the roads running around the perimeter of the square that currently hinder access and views across the space. The proposed removal of vehicle routes will represent a major positive impact, as will addressing the patchwork public realm, replac- ing considerable areas of tarmacadam with a new scheme to reinforce the historic sett-and- sandstone flag character of the square. The historically characteristic sandstone perimeter routes will be reinstated, albeit on an enlarged size to accommodate the requirement for gener- ous pedestrian circulation. Areas of the public realm that are of historic or appropriate materi- als, such as the Yorkstone paving, are being conserved as existing, with some select areas being lifted and relaid in situ. The proposed movement of elements of visual clutter such as furnishings and security features to the outer boundary of the square helps to recreate the historically characteristic openness of views. This is to some degree balanced against more harmful interventions, such as the increased level of planting to the Princess Street boundary and relatively minor instances of new features such as security bollards and bike racks, offering wider public benefits of ecology and security. The works to Albert Square will create a single-surface public space that is more usable and able to accommodate multiple functions. It will ensure that pedestrian flows are main- tained throughout the year, and during all but the largest of events. Links to Brazennose Street and Lincoln Square will be improved, with redesigned levels and improved gradients creating a more accessible space for all users, while promoting the square as a destination for pedestrians and cyclists. Mark Clifford is a senior heritage consultant at Purcell working on the Our Town Hall project.

RkJQdWJsaXNoZXIy MjgyMjA=