Context 163 - March 2020

C O N T E X T 1 6 3 : M A R C H 2 0 2 0 45 was through the council website and a digital engagement platform, with hard copies made available in the libraries and council offices. Shared consultation events took place, including joint local plan- heritage strategy presentations, workshops and drop-in sessions across the borough. Presentations were made to joint area ward forum meetings, neighbourhood planning groups, the green belt forum, conservation advisory group, Enfield Racial Equalities Council and faith group meetings. Joint workshops were also run with EnfieldYouth Parliament and local colleges. There were evening events almost weekly, supported by a social media campaign inviting comments on heritage assets and new build. Although ostensibly conventional consultation events, these proved exciting forums for discussion, building on early attempts to secure partnership and participation. For example, the draft new local plan included challenging growth options. Although there was a risk that the co-consultation could be perceived as what Arnstein calls ‘placatory’, the shared development of the new strategy with participants was recognised at these events as indicative of collaborative intent. Two workshop attendees spoke of ‘contributing’ to the development of the draft heritage strategy in terms of accepting some ownership of its content and commitment to growth. These events also offered opportunities to capture understanding of community-centred concerns that were not always manifest in formal representations. All the talking brought closer engagement, but that was not always followed up by written responses. Thirty-five sets of responses were received for the heritage strategy, with another 40 answering a question on the heritage strategy through the local plan questionnaire. Nonetheless, this represented a massive response rate compared to previous heritage consultations. Formal responses came primarily from the established groups. Being alert to themes coming out of the early engagement and beyond established stakeholder groups was therefore the more important, so that reporting could reflect on these, as well as the formal representations.Without the early work to ensure participation, the views of several communities would have been missed. Changes to the strategy’s form and content made following consultation included incorporation of a document hierarchy map, more on the SPD status, and more objectives and aims relating to inclusivity, green spaces, waterways, enforcement and interpretation. The programme of meetings and events with community groups grew over the consultation period in response to suggestions from others. In one instance, building relationships with a non-expert community group from first workshop through to focus group, to consultation event and beyond, has brought significant new content to the document. This has included community-based poetry that is now being planned for use on local site hoardings and has led to proposals for an area- based poetry project. It reflects just how heritage is embedded for the borough’s many individuals and communities. A busy web of other connections has been made. As imperfect as Arnstein’s categories may be, they resonate for good reason. In developing the new heritage strategy for Enfield, a degree of ‘citizen control’ has been achieved through participant partnerships that extended to, and beyond, expert stakeholder groups. In some respects similar to coproduction, it also built in informality. Constructive participation resulted from creating opportunities, being honest, flexible, accepting partial responses, recognising intermittent enthusiasm and renegotiating with the participant group as it changed. Vigorous attempts to secure partnership throughout the process have consequently led to a much higher strategic profile, connecting heritage directly with growth in place-making.Without Arnstein’s challenge still reverberating, a more usual-suspects approach to engagement on heritage might have been pursued.With it, the new heritage strategy reflects a deeper understanding of the diversity of value placed on Enfield’s current and future heritage, and its central importance to achieving growth. There is an exciting postscript to the adoption of Enfield’s new heritage strategy. The National Lottery Heritage Fund has identified Enfield as a funding focus area for the next five years. An Innovative Call for Projects offers both council and participants opportunities to consolidate new connections, build understanding and help deliver the strategy’s aims for individuals, groups and communities across Enfield. See https://new.enfield.gov.uk/ services/planning/heritage-strategy Harriet Bell is part of the heritage and urban design team in the planning service at Enfield Council. St John the Evangelist, Palmers Green East Enfield Lock

RkJQdWJsaXNoZXIy MjgyMjA=