Context 151 - September 2017

52 C O N T E X T 1 5 1 : S E P T E M B E R 2 0 1 7 right, and serves as a mirror in which to examine the UK attempts to grapple with intangible cultural heritage. Part 2 comprises 10 case studies from Yorkshire to Japan that drill down into the practicalities of engaging conservation in community practice. Each contribution has its own style, diagrams and layout that often reflect the subject matter. The chapter by Brigham et al on living with history in York uses the format of a conversation. Others, such as that on the Martos project workshop in Spain, employ a report style. The diagrams add to an understanding of the content although their quality, and that of some of the black-and-white images, could have been sharper. This volume brings together a wide range of theoretical issues and practical examples. It offers us real insights into the shift between established professional conservation value-centred methodologies to more people-centred approaches. No one said it was going to be easy. Bridget Turnbull is director at Gillinggate Heritage and recent past education secretary of the IHBC. Coming to the point Photographing Historic Buildings Steve Cole, Historic England, 2017, 257 pages, 490 colour photographs, paperback, ISBN 978 1 848022 69 0. Context readers who shop at https://retail. historicenglandservices.org.uk/index.html and enter PHB17 on the basket page will get a 20 per cent discount (rrp £20). Delivery free in the UK. ‘The minimum standard [in architectural photography] is to achieve a correctly exposed, sharp image, and the next most important quality is that the vertical planes of the building should be represented as vertical in the photograph,’ writes Steve Cole in the early pages of Photographing Historic Buildings . ‘This continued a standard that painters and draughtsmen had been adhering to for centuries, but it was important to re-establish it for photography as the new invention could produce very inaccurate representations of buildings. This standard for representing vertical as vertical is one we should still strive to achieve.’ That injunction to ‘keep the verticals vertical’ is indeed generally accepted as the first rule of architectural photography. Dare we ask: why? If we look at a building from fairly far away, with our eyes looking more or less towards the horizon, the building’s verticals will indeed appear vertical. But usually we look at buildings from fairly close up and looking upwards, in which case the verticals will appear to converge, in the same way as the horizontal lines on the ground plane appear to converge in what we understand as perspective. So why do photographers not photograph buildings in ways that show the convergence? Well, they do sometimes, and there are a few examples of such photographs in this book, but professional architectural photographers do not do it very often. Architectural photographers avoid showing verticals converging by choosing a viewpoint (high or far away, for example) that prevents it, or by using a specialist perspective-correcting lens, or by later manipulating the digital image. Generally architectural photographs with verticals shown as vertical look good, but they sometimes look rather odd, due to the fact that the convergence that we would expect to see in reality is missing, and the top of the building looks too wide. But to some extent our brain adjusts and ignores that distortion, in the same way as it sometimes (but not always) prevents us from noticing the converging verticals of an actual building that we are looking at. When is it appropriate to break the golden ‘vertical verticals’ rule and show verticals in a photograph converging? How can the photographer work out how much convergence will look right? (For example, a very slight convergence in a photograph usually looks incompetent. Too much convergence may make the building appear to be falling over backwards.) It would have been good to have had some discussion of those tricky questions in Photographing Historic Buildings. Cole notes that ‘the power and ease with which images can be manipulated in an editing programme is an ever- increasing temptation to modify what the camera saw.’ True, but the manipulation does not start there: what the camera saw depends on what the photographer showed it. The camera never lies (don’t blame the camera), but the photographer always interprets. Those quibbles aside, this is an exceptionally good book. Steve Cole, former head of photography at English Heritage, provides a wealth of advice that would benefit any photographer, from beginner to professional. Each of the book’s many photographs has a caption that explains an important point. Particularly useful and well- illustrated sections explain how to photograph specific subjects (staircases, for example) and how to carry out a photographic survey. There is much detailed technical advice. Some of it will probably soon become redundant. This, as Cole explains, is due to the new Light Field system of capturing images, which seems likely to revolutionise photography by doing away with the need to focus the camera and choose the correct aperture. But Cole’s guidance on the art of taking successful photographs will be of value as long as people are trying to convert the experience of seeing buildings – which usually involves being on the move, looking up and down, with our glance flitting over the surface of what is in front of us, seeing some things in focus and others in peripheral vision, and with our brains interpreting what we see – into two- dimensional, rectangular, static images. At £20 the book is good value, and there is a discount for Context readers (see above). Rob Cowan, editor of Context Thisbookguides the reader through theprocessofdocumenting thehistoric environmentusingadigital cameraand examines the standards that shouldbeapplied to thephotographs thatwe take to ensure that theywillbeavital recordof thepast. Withmore than500photographs takenby theauthorandother HistoricEnglandphotographers, thebook’s focus includes the following topics: • Composition • Usingnaturalandartificial light • Case studiesofphotographic surveys • Post-production techniques Illustrated throughoutwith examplesofgoodandbadpractice, this book setsout techniquesand strategies ina simpleand straightforward way for thosewhowant tomake theirphotographsofhistoric buildings truly effective. 9 781848022690 ISBN 978-1-84802-269-0 Photographing Historic Buildings Steve Cole Photographing Historic Buildings Steve Cole