Context 111 - September 2009

C O N T E X T 1 1 1 : S E P T E M B E R 2 0 0 9 5 Periodically It is sometimes said that we live in a highly pressured culture where a threeminute attention span is the norm. There is an insidious trend, if not to dumb-down some heritage publications, certainly to provide material in more bite-sized, ‘information-lite’ chunks. These are neither very informative, nor particularly useful. There may be a desire among some organisations to attract a wider, non-professional audience – but if knowledge is power, some periodicals appear to be underestimating the fervour of their readership for greater depth. This may ultimately be counter-productive. If subjects published at length are becoming less commonplace, it is satisfying to be able to highlight them here. It is always a pleasure to welcome the annual ASCHB Transactions (Vol 31) – the journal of Association for Studies in the Conservation of Historic Buildings – especially since it started being illustrated in colour (Vol 27). The journal is able to deal with its subject matter in depth. The resolution of complex repair and reinstatement issues and overviews dominate the latest edition. Philip Emery and Jacqueline Heath explain the works to diagnose the cause of conspicuous ongoing settlement to the South Steps of Westminster Great Hall (listed Grade I and part of the Westminster World Heritage Site). They describe the remedial works to arrest the movement in a collaboration involving engineers and archaeologists. The article highlights the value of critical appraisal of conservation priorities and managing the archaeological impact. It explains the conservation principles involved and the importance of documenting the professionals’ own decision-making. The case provided an opportunity to enhance public access and understanding, while still meeting the ever-tightening security constraints imposed by the Palace of Westminster. Clive England describes the restoration of the c1750 Bishop Sherlock’s Room at Fulham Palace. The restoration has raised substantial philosophical issues, including those of sustainability. The palace ceased to be the rural seat of the Bishops of London in 1973, after almost 1,300 years. The article deals with the first phase of the master plan initiated in 2005-6. This phase reinstated a magnificent room, which had been converted to a kitchen in c1816 by SP Cockerell and was used more recently as a computer room. The third of the complex issues concerns the roof of the Reform Club in Pall Mall (Grade I). This is one of the best Victorian buildings in Britain, designed by Charles Barry and completed in 1841. The splendid and unusual slate roof is now covered with Italian terracotta tiles. The article traces the history and problems of this ‘patent slated’ roof. Various solutions were debated, such as lead reproofing imitating slate and attempted replication in slate, before the covering was changed for something completely different. The article describes the various technical issues faced by the architect, the tile manufacturer and the contractor. The two overviews differ markedly. The first is written by Alasdair Glass, formerly senior project director at English Heritage and now a consultant architect at Donald Insall Associates. Glass reviews the 50 years of building conservation undertaken by Insall, as expressed in Living Buildings, Insall’s recent follow-up to his 1972 book Care of Old Buildings Today. The new book has a different purpose, and Glass sees this as a valedictory testament to an exceptional and long career. The text concentrates on what really matters now, rather than ‘the ephemeral trivia which can threaten to overwhelm practical common sense’. The second overview is by John Fidler, formerly conservation director at English Heritage and now a resident of sunny southern California. Fidler is well placed to take as his point of departure the recent 40th anniversary of the Association of Preservation Technology, and comparisons between UK and US practice. He makes telling observations about American insularity – fewer than 20 per cent of US citizens have passports, compared to 81 per cent in the UK – and relative cultural isolation. Fidler highlights the size of the US building professionals (and the lack of a national body representing structural engineers), obvious differences in the approach to legislation (and our ‘common language’), and the effects of extreme climate ranges across the North American continent on buildings and their conservation. Fidler describes the methods of work in his Los Angeles practice, and illustrates some of the remarkably varied heritage projects carried out by his firm Simpson, Gumpertz and Heger. He concludes with a fascinating case study: the extensive repair of Frank Lloyd Wright’s Ennis House in Hollywood (a location for Ridley Scott’s Blade Runner), constructed of concrete blocks influenced by Mayan architecture. This journal is a very wellillustrated and fascinating read, and well worth seeking out. The July 2009 edition of the Journal of Architectural Conservation (Vol 15, No 2) has five very interesting and wide-ranging articles. These are likely to be of interest and relevance to conservation practitioners, because of the thoroughness with which they address their subjects. The severely decayed listed boathouse at Belton House in Lincolnshire, owned by the National Trust, is an early work of Anthony Salvin and a rare surviving

RkJQdWJsaXNoZXIy MjgyMjA=