C O N T E X T 1 1 1 : S E P T E M B E R 2 0 0 9 47 IHBC consultation responses Telling them what we think IHBC consultations consultant James Caird writes: I have been coordinating the institute’s responses to government and other consultations for just over two years. In this time just over 100 consultations have been considered, with responses on about 80 per cent of them being merited, not including some pertaining wholly to the devolved administrations which have been dealt with by the relevant branch of the institute. This article is the first of a regular series reviewing the responses submitted by the institute. An overall theme of our responses to consultations recently has been that heritage assets should be seen as a resource and a valuable component of sustainable development, and not as an inconvenient constraint that gets in the way of other policy objectives. We repeatedly note emerging advice where environmental considerations are required to be taken into account but without any environmental assessment or contextual analysis being required. It seems that these simple points are sufficiently outside the experience of policy draughtsmen not to surface without prompting. We responded to the review of the criteria for designation of world heritage sites.We supported the proposal to be more critical of candidates for UK submissions to UNESCO, bearing in mind their proposal to broaden the geographic cultural ranges of world heritage site designation.We agreed that there was little point in progressing UK proposals that had little chance of designation.We asked that active steps be taken to address the imbalance between sites in England and the devolved administrations. We also thought that better longterm commitment to maintenance of our existing sites was required. We commented on Delivering a Sustainable Transport System that environmental appraisal should be required for any significant scheme. This was also missing in the consultation on eco-towns. This required eco-towns to be located near to existing sustainable settlements without requiring any assessment of the impact of the proposed association on the neighbouring settlement. The institute felt that this could be particularly detrimental to historic towns. There was also a preoccupation with housing that did not adequately support the formation of socially and economically self-sufficient settlements. The response by the Scottish branch on householder permitted development rights followed in the footsteps of those in England and Northern Ireland with an emphasis on stricter control in designated areas. The Scottish branch also responded on Designing Streets, commenting generally on the need to minimise street clutter and avoid schemes which radically altered traditional townscape, with more sensitively chosen case studies. One of the recurring issues in recent consultations has been the extent to which heritage assets can appropriately contribute to climate change targets. The government’s favoured approach is to set rigid performance targets with as few exceptions as possible. The institute has advocated a different approach for historic assets of requiring an assessment to be made of a building’s potential to contribute to energy saving without compromising its historic character, and for that contribution to be implemented.We commented in this way on Definition of Zero Carbon Homes and Non-domestic Buildings and on the Heat and Energy-saving Strategy, in which we felt that the aspirations were unlikely to be matched with resources, and that the strategy was let down by the lack of proper whole-life energy audit of components and processes. We were very disappointed with Natural England’s document Future Landscapes (and its sister document All Landscapes Matter) which we felt lacked focus and failed to set out any sort of vision for the way in which future policy would deliver landscape protection and improvement. Several recent consultations have been about major infrastructure which will affect landscapes. Some of these have been about national policy statements for infrastructure, which will come in due course before the Infrastructure Planning Commission. The national policy statements will be the only policy in front of the IPC when it makes decisions which are single development consents displacing the need for normal planning consents, including listed building and conservation area consents. So it is vitally important that national policy statements contain adequate advice about heritage assets. The consultation on eco-towns also dealt inadequately with landscape assessment. In the case of Choosing Sites for Nuclear Power Stations, we asked for better environmental assessment procedures in the setting of proposals as well as for the sites themselves.We asked for a widening the list of Statutory Consultees for National Policy Statements to include interests in the devolved administrations.We commented at some length on Applications for Nationally Significant Infrastructure Projects. The issue here was principally that the rules minimised the amount of material that applicants were to be required to submit with applications to the extent that assessment of the proposal by third parties would be impossible. We asked for a procedure equivalent to the design and access statement to be included in the requirements. Finally, we commented on the proposals for INSPIRE, the Europewide proposal for the recording and availability of on-line environmental information.While supporting the principles, we were concerned that the proposals were resource-hungry and might divert those of us working for local authorities from our core work of protecting heritage assets. All members of the institute are able to participate in the consideration of consultations: contact me at consultations@ihbc.org.uk. The responses themselves are all available on the website http://www.ihbc.org. uk/consultations_archive.htm.
RkJQdWJsaXNoZXIy MjgyMjA=