C O N T E X T 1 1 1 : S E P T E M B E R 2 0 0 9 31 IHBC Annual School 2009 IHBC Annual School 2009 IHBC Annual School 2009 BRIDGET PEREIRA The social cost of conserving Brasilia Brazil’s capital needs to reconcile its social housing and urban conservation challenges, while restoring the egalitarian values at the heart of its original plan. The modernist city of Brasilia has been described as both ‘a masterpiece of creative genius’1 and ‘a city divided between the rich and the poor’.2 As the population of Brazil’s Federal District increases, growth is concentrated around the surrounding satellite cities, while the population of the world heritage site decreases. Today the city has a population of around 300,000 high-earning inhabitants. However, close to 1.3 million people live in the surrounding conurbation of satellite cities, many living a hand-tomouth existence.3 Speculative pressure has been cited by UNESCO as the main threat to the continued conservation of Lucio Costa’s plan, but what are the social consequences of their heritage restrictions?4 This article explores the social impact of conserving Brasilia’s pilot plan. In 1957 Brazil’s administrative capital was moved from Rio de Janeiro and created ex nihilo in the vast interior savannah lands of the Central Brazilian High Plateau. The resulting federal district (BrasiliaFederal District) spanned an area of 5,814km² with a purpose-built modernist capital at its centre.5 It was an astounding feat for urbanism, even by today’s standards. Designed by the architect and planner Lucio Costa, the plan, named the pilot plan, took the form of an aeroplane. Costa was heavily influenced by Le Corbusier’s Radiant City and socialist ideas of collectivism, envisaging Brasilia as a utopian city where benefits would be evenly distributed among all residents regardless of income or status. In order to build the new capital, large swathes of farmland were bought up by the government, and construction workers were drafted in from across Brazil. As a result, temporary make-shift settlements began to spring up around the pilot plan area to house workers. With time these evolved into permanent satellite cities and shanty towns, becoming a part of the urban fabric of the federal district.The final plan included provision for social housing and a population cap of 600,000 people. An expansion plan was also put forward which comprised five additional urban archipelagos intended to absorb overspill but never outgrow the original city. The city was officially inaugurated in 1960. Within the year a federal law had been passed to conserve its original layout, which gave the government absolute power over development. However, by 1964 the political tide had turned and a military junta seized power. Under the new capitalist agenda the government-owned residential land was sold off to private developers and the opportunity for social housing was lost. Levels of residential stratification were exacerbated by a government policy of demolishing make-shift housing in the pilot plan and forcibly resettling poorer residents on the periphery of the city. Crucially, Costa’s expansion plan was scrapped, making way for uncontrolled development on the city’s periphery. Brasilia was inscribed on the UNESCO World Heritage List in 1987, becoming the first 20th century monument to be awarded such protection. The decree was based on Costa’s original master plan and protected the relationship between the built and unbuilt areas, thereby preventing further development. However, it failed to conserve the social aims that lay behind Costa’s plan instead conserving a socially stratified, capitalist city in a modernist style. There is a growing body of evidence to suggest that restrictive urban land use controls have adverse social consequences. In Brazil, 81 per cent of the population lives in urban areas. In the central-west region which encompasses Brasilia, 86 per cent of the total population lives in cities.6 Brazil has one of the highest levels of income inequality in the world, with 38 per cent of the population living below the poverty line.7 Through the analysis of patterns of income distribution in the central and peripheral areas of Brasilia and five other Brazilian cities, it has become clear that in Brasilia these inequalities are amplified as a result of the planning restrictions. Highly effective conservation restrictions preventing further development inside the heritage boundaries, compounded by a state monopoly on land ownership within the 0–5km radius of the pilot plan and a background of damaging government policies, References 1 UNESCO (2008) BrasiliaWorld Heritage 2 Miranda, R (2007) Entrevista Oscar Niemeyer, Correiro Braziliense, 18 March 3 Instituto Brasileiro de Geografia e Estatistica (2003) Censo Demografico 2000, Brasilia, IBGE 4 World Heritage Committee (2003) Convention concerning the protection of the world cultural and natural heritage 5 UNESCO (2008) BrasiliaWorld Heritage 6 Avila, PC and Mandell, PI (2005) Interpretation of population density gradients, Third Urban Research Symposium on Land Development, Urban Policy and Poverty Reduction, Brasilia, April 7 World Bank Group (2007) Brazil Country Brief,World Bank 8 Pereira, B (2008) People versus Buildings: has the safeguarding of architectural unity in Brasilia encouraged residential stratification by income between the pilot plan and the periphery? MSc Dissertation, University of Edinburgh 9 Avila, PC and Mandell, PI (2005) op cit 10 Habitat International Coalition. (nd) Popular Strategies in Historic Urban Centers,Vol 2: Europe 11 Fernandes, E (2007) ‘Constructing the “Right to the City” in Brazil’, Social Legal Studies (16) 201 National Congress, Brasilia Brazil from Google Maps
RkJQdWJsaXNoZXIy MjgyMjA=