Context 111 - September 2009

C O N T E X T 1 1 1 : S E P T E M B E R 2 0 0 9 19 IHBC Annual School 2009 IHBC Annual School 2009 IHBC Annual School 2009 water, materials and waste, land use, and ecology and pollution. BREEAM-In-Use is a new scheme specifically designed for existing, non-residential, buildings. It is especially relevant to those who care for historic buildings. It offers building managers ‘a clear and credible route-map to improving sustainability’. For IHBC members such statements can raise stress levels, as proposals for radical alterations to windows and floors often follow. There is always a risk that the demands to improve environmental performance will defeat our efforts to preserve special historic character. But Carney assured us that the BREEAM-In-Use process was weighted to take account of this. ‘Energy use is not the be-all and end-all,’ he said. ‘There are other factors in the assessment.’ One member of the group carefully probed deeper into how cultural value was assessed. For example, did the overall score adequately reflect whether historic features had been removed or retained in the process of making energy-saving improvements? While the methodology may aim to value historic character, I got the impression that there might be too much reliance on the individual person carrying out the certification assessment and how well their assessments were monitored by the BRE. I was surprised to learn that it was possible to obtain certification online just by answering about 150 questions. On the other hand, I was encouraged to hear Carney stress the importance of ongoing management of how a building is used. No amount of positive certification will help if the process does not lead to ‘greater engagement with staff in implementing sustainability’. The assessment rewards systems as well as their proper implementation. Carney said that the BREEAM-Inby saying that more appropriate models and ways of testing were required. Any advice on good practice would be gratefully received. Wood advocated the need for careful repair and maintenance to buildings, as well as providing good advice on housekeeping: the assumptions used to produce energy performance certificates were heavily biased against historic buildings. Mark Price, planning and architectural advisor for the Theatres Trust The potential of BREEAM-In-Use Philip Carney Philip Carney led a very instructive and interactive afternoon class on BREEAM (Building Research Establishment Environmental Assessment Method)- In-Use and how it is promoting sustainability in existing buildings. He began by explaining where BREEAMIn-Use fitted within the whole Building Research Establishment (BRE) structure covering research, consultancy and certification. I had not realised that BRE was a charitable trust. BREEAM, which comes under BREGlobal, is the world’s leading environmental assessment method for buildings, setting standards for best practice in sustainable design. BREEAM can be used to assess the environmental performance of any type of building, including the less common types (such as prisons) that have bespoke assessment systems. Buildings are assessed under the categories of management, health and wellbeing, energy, transport, Pod classrooms in the converted railway works at Derby provide a sustainable alternative to heating the whole building to classroom temperature, and required minimal alteration to historic fabric. (Photo: Jonathan Taylor)

RkJQdWJsaXNoZXIy MjgyMjA=